Inside the Controversy: Justin Baldoni’s Ex-Publicist Unleashes Scathing Critique Ahead of High-Stakes Trial
A storm of controversy has erupted as Justin Baldoni’s former publicist, Sarah Ellington, publicly condemned the actor’s legal and PR strategies ahead of a pivotal 2026 trial. The case, which involves high-profile testimonies including Blake Lively’s, has drawn intense scrutiny, with questions now swirling about Ryan Reynolds’ potential involvement. The dispute centers on allegations of mismanagement and ethical breaches, escalating tensions in an already volatile legal battle.
Behind the Public Fallout
Ellington, who worked with Baldoni from 2018 to 2022, broke her silence in a candid interview with The Hollywood Reporter, accusing the actor and his team of “reckless decision-making” and “toxic damage control.” Her remarks come as Baldoni faces a defamation lawsuit filed by a former business partner, with the trial set to begin in January 2026.
“The strategies employed were not just ineffective—they were destructive,” Ellington stated. “Instead of addressing the core issues, they opted for short-term optics, which only deepened the legal and reputational risks.” Industry analysts suggest her critique could influence public perception ahead of the trial, where Blake Lively is expected to testify as a key witness.
The High-Stakes Legal Battle
The lawsuit, filed in 2023, alleges Baldoni made defamatory statements about his ex-business partner during a podcast interview. Legal experts estimate the case could result in damages exceeding $10 million, given the plaintiff’s claims of lost revenue and reputational harm. Court documents reveal that Lively’s testimony may focus on Baldoni’s character and professional conduct, adding star power to an already sensational case.
Ryan Reynolds’ potential involvement remains uncertain. While not named in the lawsuit, sources close to the case speculate he could be subpoenaed due to his ties with Lively and Baldoni. “Reynolds’ testimony could be a wildcard,” said legal analyst Mark Harrison. “His perspective on Baldoni’s public persona might sway the jury, especially if the defense leans on his credibility.”
Industry Reactions and Ethical Debates
Ellington’s critique has ignited broader conversations about celebrity PR tactics. A 2025 survey by the Public Relations Society of America found that 68% of PR professionals believe high-profile clients often prioritize image over transparency, increasing long-term risks. “Celebrities frequently confuse silencing critics with resolving conflicts,” noted crisis management expert Dr. Lila Chen. “This case exemplifies why that approach backfires.”
However, Baldoni’s current team has pushed back. In a statement to Variety, his spokesperson called Ellington’s comments “a mischaracterization of events” and emphasized their “commitment to ethical and strategic legal responses.” Supporters of the actor point to his philanthropic work, arguing the controversy overshadows his positive contributions.
What’s Next for Baldoni and the Trial?
With the trial looming, legal teams are preparing for a media frenzy. Key developments to watch include:
- Blake Lively’s testimony: Scheduled for February 2026, her appearance could draw unprecedented attention.
- Ryan Reynolds’ role: If subpoenaed, his involvement would escalate the case’s celebrity factor.
- Public sentiment: Ellington’s remarks may sway opinion, potentially impacting jury selection.
As the drama unfolds, the case serves as a cautionary tale about the intersection of fame, ethics, and litigation. For now, all eyes remain on the courtroom—and the court of public opinion.
Stay updated on this developing story by subscribing to our entertainment newsletter for exclusive insights and analysis.
See more The Buzz Live